Below is the Class 1 All-State softball team as voted on by the coaches.
NOTE: All information is posted as submitted.
| 2021 Class 1 Softball All State Teams | ||||
| Pitchers-1st Team | Pitchers-2nd Team | |||
| Name | School | Name | School | |
| Olivia Coy | La Plata | Hanna Vaught | Polo | |
| Hailey LeMunyon | Maysville | Jordan Moore | East Carter | |
| Taylor Howard | Silex | Riley Hammond | St. Elizabeth | |
| Abbie Farmer | Atlanta | Emma Hall | Braymer | |
| Catchers-1st Team | Catchers-2nd Team | |||
| Ashley Brown | Maysville | Caleigh Chilton | East Carter | |
| Chloe Gilbert | Polo | Kinsey Biggerstaff | Canton | |
| Claire Coy | La Plata | Lexus Hagood | Neelyville | |
| Infielders-1st Team | Infielders-2nd Team | |||
| Pieper Wood | La Plata | Karissa Rogers | Braymer | |
| Kayla Larkins | Polo | Abagail Mooney | Silex | |
| Ashton Willis | Maysville | Tori Kemna | St. Elizabeth | |
| Tasia Green | St. Elizabeth | Carsey Brown | Princeton | |
| Rylee O’Dell | East Carter | Dixie Cloud | Neelyville | |
| Jaka Sharp | Halfway | Hannah Feeney | Scotland Co. | |
| Outfielders-1st Team | Outfielders-2nd Team | |||
| Rylie Boyer | Maysville | Claire Catlett | Maysville | |
| Whitney Mitchell | Naylor | Gwen Gilbert | Silex | |
| Paige Carvajal | La Plata | Abi Ogle | Cairo | |
| Chesnie Robbins | North Shelby | |||
| Lexi Craig | Stanberry | |||
| At Large-1st Team | At Large-2nd Team | |||
| Reese Dobbins | Neelyville | Kait Hatfield | Schuyler Co. | |
