Lamar led the way on the All-Big 8 football team with both Cooper Lucas and T.W. Ayers taking the Offensive and Defensive Player of the Year honors, respectively. Seneca coach Ryan McFarland was named the Coach of the Year for guiding the Indians to a turnaround season that saw them go 8-1 and finish as conference runner-up.
See the full teams below.
FIRST TEAM
| Offense | ||
| QB: | John Dakota Lee | Aurora |
| RB: | Cooper Lucas | Lamar |
| RB: | Isrrael DeSantiago | McDonald County |
| RB: | Trey Wilson | Seneca |
| WR: | Clayton Dunning* | Aurora |
| WR: | Andrew Montemayor | Mt. Vernon |
| WR: | DJ White | Cassville |
| TE: | T.W. Ayers | Lamar |
| Tackle: | Coy Butterworth | Monett |
| Tackle: | Caleb Gouge | Lamar |
| Guard: | Seth Fullerton* | Lamar |
| Guard: | Lane Fanning | Lamar |
| Guard: | Elliott Wolfe | McDonald County |
| Center: | Cameron Augusta* | Lamar |
| All Purpose: | Michael Danner | Lamar |
| Kicker: | Jayden Buttram* | Mt. Vernon |
| POY: | Cooper Lucas | Lamar |
| Coach of the Year: | Ryan McFarland | Seneca |
| Defense | ||
| DE: | Cooper Lucas | Lamar |
| DE: | T.W. Ayers | Lamar |
| DT: | Andrew Hillman | Lamar |
| DT: | Hunter Bayless | Lamar |
| LB: | Will Boswell* | Mt. Vernon |
| LB: | Travis Bailey* | Lamar |
| LB: | Wyatt Goade | Cassville |
| LB: | Kale Schrader | Seneca |
| DB: | Clayton Dunning | Aurora |
| DB: | Michael Danner* | Lamar |
| DB: | Landon Hardman | Lamar |
| DB: | Max Roark | Seneca |
| DB: | Garret Knight | Cassville |
| Returner Spec: | Andrew Montemayor* | Mt. Vernon |
| Punter: | Peyton Barton | McDonald County |
| POY: | T.W. Ayers | Lamar |
SECOND TEAM
| Offense | ||
| QB: | Gavin Clouse | Seneca |
| RB: | Sammy Robinson | Mt. Vernon |
| RB: | Patrick Valentine | Monett |
| RB: | Anthony Tolbert | Cassville |
| WR: | Dustin McDermott | East Newton |
| WR: | Kennedy Hodson | McDonald County |
| WR: | Max Roark | Seneca |
| TE: | Kadin Clark | Aurora |
| Tackle: | Andrew Hillman | Lamar |
| Tackle: | Zac Whittlesey | East Newton |
| Gaurd: | Eli Dodson | Seneca |
| Gaurd: | Hunter Bailey | Cassville |
| Center: | Laine Doty | Seneca |
| All Purpose: | Logan Lauffer | Aurora |
| Kicker: | Nathan Wall | East Newton |
| Defense | ||
| DE: | Gavin Dunnam | Seneca |
| DE: | Coy Butterworth | Monett |
| DT: | Carson Dake | Mt. Vernon |
| DT: | Adam Long | Monett |
| LB: | Connor Savage | Aurora |
| LB: | J.D. Bishop | Lamar |
| LB: | Cole DelosSantos | McDonald Cnty |
| LB: | Isrrael DeSantiago | McDonald Cnty |
| DB: | Dylan Hill | Lamar |
| DB: | Oakley Roessler | McDonald Cnty |
| DB: | Dawson Stephens | Seneca |
| DB: | Andrew Montemayor | Mt. Vernon |
| Returner Spec: | Landon Hardman | Lamar |
| Punter: | Shannon Haney | Cassville |
HONORABLE MENTION
| Offense | ||
| QB: | Stuart McKarus | Lamar |
| RB: | Trevor Medlin | Lamar |
| RB: | Cole Hatfield | Seneca |
| RB: | Brett Pendergraft | East Newton |
| WR: | Chance Fenton | Mt. Vernon |
| WR: | Jedd Anderson | Monett |
| WR: | Ethan Johnston | Mt. Vernon |
| TE: | Gavin Dunnam | Seneca |
| Tackle: | Colton Hicks | Mt. Vernon |
| Tackle: | Grant Davis | Cassville |
| Gaurd: | Brendan Castleberry | Aurora |
| Gaurd: | Carson Dake | Mt. Vernon |
| Center: | Braydan Clouse | East Newton |
| Center: | Luke McKenzie | Mt. Vernon |
| All Purpose: | Shannon Haney | Cassville |
| Kicker: | Dylan Allison | McDonald County |
| Defense | ||
| DE: | Cayden Heisner | Mt. Vernon |
| DE: | Zack Burton | Cassville |
| DT: | Caleb Coffey | East Newton |
| DT: | Trey Black | McDonald County |
| DT: | Luke McKenzie | Mt. Vernon |
| LB: | Aaron Moenning | Lamar |
| LB: | David Roark | McDonald County |
| LB: | Harris Griffith | Seneca |
| LB: | Patrick Valentine | Monett |
| DB: | Brett Pendergraft | East Newton |
| DB: | Chance Fenton | Mt. Vernon |
| DB: | Braden Strahan | Cassville |
| Returner Spec: | Logan Lauffer | Aurora |
| Punter: | Dawson Stephens | Seneca |
