Class 3—District 11 champion West Plains had four players selected to the all-district softball team. Reeds Spring led the field with nine all-district selections.
| First Team | Second Team | |||
| Pitchers | Pitchers | |||
| 1. | Abbey Gann, JR, West Plains | 1. | Caitlyn Blackburn, JR, Hillcrest | |
| 2. | Hunter Bledsoe, JR, Rogersville | |||
| 3. | Izzy Erickson, FR, Reeds Spring | |||
| Catchers | Catchers | |||
| 1. | Shelby Ince, FR, Rogersville | 1. | Maddison Cantrell, FR, Reeds Spring | |
| 2. | Alexa Bekemeier, JR, Hollister | 2. | Maddison Shafferkoetter, SO, Hillcrest | |
| 3. | Alyssa Sims, SO, West Plains | |||
| Infielders | Infielders | |||
| 1. | Allie Dickerson, SR, Reeds Spring | 1. | Riah Green, JR, Hollister | |
| 2. | Haley Frillman, SO, Hillcrest | 2. | Lydia Conlon, SO, Hillcrest | |
| 3. | Kasey Bonham, JR, West Plains | 3. | Courtney Scobee, SO, Reeds Spring | |
| 4. | Mackenzie Duvall, JR, Reeds Spring | 4. | Dusty Welch, SO, Reeds Spring | |
| 5. | KK Thomas, JR, Hollister | 5. | ||
| 6. | ||||
| Outfielders | Outfielders | |||
| 1. | Hailey Brown, JR, Rogersville | 1. | Abby Rudd, SO, Reeds Spring | |
| 2. | Karsyn Smith, JR, West Plains | 2. | ||
| 3. | Hannah Erickson, SR, Reeds Spring | 3. | ||
| UT | UT | |||
| 1. | Julia Marshall, SO, Rogersville | 1. | Maddie Walker, SR, Reeds Spring | |
